In her media interview, Thórsdóttir reflected on her past stating, "It's been 36 years, a lot of things change in that time and I would definitely have dealt with these issues differently today." The relationship with the boy, identified as Eirík Ásmundsson, became public knowledge following an inquiry linked to a family member of Ásmundsson. In the interview, Thórsdóttir expressed her distress over the circumstances of the revelation, highlighting her belief that it is challenging to convey the complete story in today's news landscape.

Despite the age of consent being 15 in Iceland, Thórsdóttir faced scrutiny as it is illegal for teachers or mentors to engage in sexual activity with individuals under the age of 18 if there is a financial dependency involved. This situation raises serious questions about the responsibilities of public officials, particularly in light of the minister's position over vulnerable children.

While Thórsdóttir has left her ministerial role, she confirmed her intention to retain her position in parliament, signifying a complex turn in her political career as Iceland continues to navigate the fallout from this controversial revelation.