Former managers of the Countess of Chester Hospital in England are urging a judge to halt the ongoing public inquiry into nurse Lucy Letby, who was convicted for murdering seven babies under her care. Their lawyer, Kate Blackwell, stated that new evidence suggests the infants’ deaths might be due to natural causes or poor medical management, rather than intentional harm by Letby.

Blackwell articulated the importance of fully recognizing these alternative explanations during the inquiry to achieve its purpose. Letby, who maintains her innocence, was found guilty in a series of trials, leading to the establishment of the inquiry to investigate how such crimes could go undetected. As new questions arise regarding the validity of her convictions, an independent panel concluded that there is no concrete evidence of foul play by Letby, supporting claims that the infants’ fatalities were attributed to mismanagement or natural causes.

With substantial skepticism emerging around the initial findings, this inquiry stands at a pivotal moment, where the implications of these new developments could reshape public perception and legal outcomes regarding Letby's culpability.