With Vice President JD Vance calling Charlie Kirk “a martyr for Christianity,” and a Catholic cardinal dubbing him “a modern-day St. Paul,” his admirers speculate that his recent assassination may galvanize young conservatives to engage more deeply in both evangelical and Catholic churches.
Almost immediately after Kirk's death on September 10, calls for a revival of Kirk-inspired religious fervor began to swell, especially during the VIP-attended memorial service that felt reminiscent of a massive megachurch gathering. Reports indicate a surge in attendance at numerous evangelical churches following the event.
“Charlie had big plans, but God had bigger plans,” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth remarked during the service. “He initiated a political movement but unleashed a spiritual revival.”
The Rev. Robert Jeffress, a prominent evangelical leader from a megachurch in Dallas, remarked via email that the emotional outpouring following Kirk’s death is reminiscent of the reactions to other national tragedies. “The short-term impact of Kirk’s murder is astounding,” he noted, expressing hope for its long-term effects.
What the trends tell us about revival
A sustained surge in church attendance would conflict with current trends. Political scientist Ryan Burge stated that historical data shows no examples of enduring religious revivals following civic traumas, recalling a brief spike in attendance post-9/11 that quickly faded.
Burge reasoned, “For a significant impact on church attendance, millions would need to change their behavior, which is a daunting task in a nation of over 340 million.” Even in a best-case scenario of a long-term upswing, he believes it would take at least 18 months to provide any reliable data.
Reports of new faces and crowded pews
Regardless of the future, many conservative Christian congregations report an influx of new members. Gina Gleason, of Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, notes an increase in church attendance attributed to Kirk’s assassination, particularly among youth who resonated with his political engagement.
Similarly, Pastor Mark Francey of Oceans Church reported a notable attendance increase, suggesting a “9/11 type effect” with a rise in people turning to spirituality in the wake of tragedy.
Testimonies shared by ‘The Charlie Kirk Show’
Numerous testimonies surfaced in a montage aired on “The Charlie Kirk Show,” with individuals stating they returned to church for the first time in years; sharing personal commitments to faith living inspired by Kirk's legacy.
What the local church can do
J.P. De Gance, founder of an evangelism ministry, observed increased attendance at services across multiple states and emphasized the necessity for churches to respond authentically to this moment as a movement of the Holy Spirit.
Catholics and critics join the conversation
Though Kirk identified as a Protestant, notable Catholic figures also recognized his impact, with Cardinal Timothy Dolan calling him a modern-day evangelist. However, not all responses were positive; critics highlighted the divisive narratives Kirk sometimes propagated.
David Gibson from Fordham University suggests that while some predict a revival, historical patterns indicate that such trends may not endure, likely leading to an evolution of conservative Christianity rather than a full resurgence.
